Part 3 of The Season We Built, a series on how November and December came to be the way they are.
Someone else’s working day
I remember my first Christmas Eve as a newly ordained priest, serving as associate pastor on the east side of Indianapolis. A cold rain was falling. I had celebrated the children’s Mass late that afternoon so families could go home to their Christmas Eve meals and prepare gifts for the children. The pastor had gone to visit friends, and I was scheduled to celebrate Midnight Mass. With no invitations for the hours in between, I stayed alone in the rectory.
Christmas Eve had always been a special time in my family. We gathered at my parents’ home for dinner and opened gifts afterward—a tradition I loved and looked forward to every year. Now I was spending my first Christmas Eve away from home, in an empty rectory with nothing to eat and no Christmas tree. The pastor waited until Christmas Day to put it up. No restaurants were open. My family had postponed opening gifts until Christmas evening, when I could make the two-hour drive home, but that did little to ease the loneliness that night. Frankly, I was miserable.
The families who had attended the afternoon Mass were beginning their celebrations. I was waiting to lead the next one.
We speak about the holidays as though everyone steps out of ordinary life together. Work stops. Families gather. There is time to sit at a table without watching the clock.
But the person serving that meal may be watching the clock very closely. Her own gathering might be over before she gets home.
Somewhere, a nurse is halfway through a shift. A hotel housekeeper is preparing a room for arriving guests. A driver is bringing the package someone ordered just in time. Their working day makes someone else’s holiday possible.
In the previous article, I wrote about how the season was assembled. The traditions we inherited were shaped by people making decisions, solving problems, and pursuing interests. Once we see that history, another question follows.
Who gets to stop working when the holiday arrives?
Who the holidays work for
Consider what has to be true for the familiar holiday picture to work.
You need time away from your job. You need enough money to travel, or enough space to receive the people traveling to you. You need groceries, perhaps presents, and some confidence that the expense will not leave you short when the next bill arrives. The people you want to see need schedules that fit yours.
None of that is extravagant. It is also far from guaranteed.
An invitation to come for Thanksgiving means something different to a person with paid time off than it does to someone who would lose a day’s wages. An early family dinner may be convenient for almost everyone except the relative whose shift ends at six. A gathering planned months in advance offers little certainty to someone still waiting for next week’s work schedule.
Research from the Shift Project, which studies workers at large retail and food-service employers, documents the short notice and last-minute changes many encounter. Those findings concern working life throughout the year. During the holidays, the implications are easy to recognize: you cannot confidently promise to be at the table if you do not yet know whether you will be at work.
The invitation may be sincere. The circumstances still decide who can accept it.
That is one way a holiday comes to feel universal. The people who can participate see one another participating. Those who cannot become the missing cousin, the neighbor who never comes, the daughter who will try to stop by later. Their absence looks personal, even when its cause is a work schedule.
Who works the holidays
There are good reasons some work continues.
People need care on Christmas morning. Fires do not wait until December 26. Electricity, water, and emergency services cannot simply close for the family gathering.
Other work continues because we have come to expect it. We want the restaurant open, the room ready, the shelves stocked, and the package delivered before we leave town.
Those expectations deserve a closer look. A hospital shift and a last-minute shopping trip make very different claims on someone’s time. Calling both inevitable saves us the trouble of deciding which conveniences are worth asking another person to provide.
This does not mean everyone working a holiday resents it. Someone may welcome an extra shift, prefer another day off, or have no attachment to the occasion. A person who does not celebrate Christmas may be quite happy to work on December 25.
The question is how much say that person has.
Can they volunteer? Can they decline? Can they trade a shift without losing income they need? Are the inconvenient hours shared, or do the same people keep absorbing them?
A holiday schedule can look reasonable from the customer’s side of the counter and quite different from behind it. The customer sees an open business. The employee knows how the decision was made.
The price of being available
We tend to recognize the cost of holiday work when it produces a touching story: the parent who misses a child opening presents, the nurse who eats dinner from a container, the family that celebrates a day late.
But the cost does not always arrive as a dramatic sacrifice. Sometimes it is the repeated uncertainty of being unable to make plans. Sometimes it is having to ask everyone else to wait. Sometimes it is the knowledge that asking for time off could mean a smaller paycheck.
Money changes how much room a person has to maneuver. So do staffing levels, workplace protections, and the willingness of a supervisor to listen.
It would be too simple to divide the world into salaried people enjoying themselves and hourly people serving them. Plenty of professionals work holidays, and plenty of hourly workers have arrangements that suit them. The meaningful difference is the ability to influence what happens to your time.
When that ability is limited, even a loving family can add pressure. Everyone wants you there. Everyone wonders whether you could ask again. Eventually, you are explaining a decision you did not get to make.
We call the season a time for togetherness. We should notice how much negotiating some people must do to obtain it.
Work follows us through the front door
Even when everyone arrives, the work has not ended.
Someone has planned the meal, remembered the dietary restrictions, found the extra chairs, and worked out when the oven needs to be free. Afterward, someone will still be standing at the sink while the conversation continues in the other room.
This work can be an expression of love. Enjoying it does not make it effortless.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ time-use research shows that women spend more time on household activities than men, including among people employed full time. That is a year-round finding, rather than a measurement of holiday preparations, but it gives us reason to question the assumption that the work at home distributes itself.
I will return to that household labor later in this series. For now, it belongs in the same picture as the paid work outside the house. The season’s ease depends on effort that can disappear from view once the meal is served and the guests are comfortable.
It is possible for everyone to be home and still not everyone to have a holiday.
What gratitude ought to change
Thanking someone who is working on a holiday is a decent thing to do. There is no need to become suspicious of ordinary kindness.
But gratitude becomes thin when it asks nothing of the person expressing it.
If I thank a worker for being there and then become impatient because service is slow, what have I recognized? If I praise the person who prepared dinner but leave every dish for that person to wash, how much has my appreciation accomplished?
Employers face larger questions. How early are schedules available? How are holiday assignments decided? What compensation and time off accompany them? Is there enough staff for people to do the work without being worn down?
Customers and families have choices, too. We can distinguish an actual need from something we would merely prefer. We can accept that a business closes. We can arrange a gathering around the person with the least flexible schedule. At home, we can take responsibility for a task before someone has to assign it.
None of these choices settles every question about wages or working conditions. They do change what we ask other people to absorb for our convenience.
A place at the table includes time to sit there
I do not want a season in which we become so worried about imposing on anyone that we stop gathering. Shared meals, travel, gifts, and celebrations can be worth considerable effort. People often give that effort gladly.
I want us to become more curious about the arrangements beneath the celebration.
Who had a choice? Who could afford to say no? Who rearranged a day, lost income, or hurried through a meal so that the rest of us could take our time?
A family can be generous and still organize its holiday around the people with the easiest schedules. A business can praise its employees and give them little influence over their hours. A guest can love the host and fail to notice that the host has barely sat down.
These are arrangements we can examine and change. The season was built through human decisions. We keep building it whenever we decide whose time will bend around whose.
Before we ask whether everyone has a place at the table, we might ask whether everyone has been given time to sit there.
Whose work makes your holiday possible—and what would make the day more of a holiday for them?