A Comparative Look at Interior Castles, Dark Night of the Soul, and the Shadow

The spiritual journey of an individual is often marked by various stages, challenges, and insights. The works of great mystics and thinkers have tried to capture these stages and experiences to guide others in their spiritual quest. This essay compares three important concepts from different spiritual traditions: St. Teresa of Avila’s “Interior Castles,” St. John of the Cross’s “Dark Night of the Soul,” and Carl Jung’s “Shadow.” These three concepts, though derived from different sources, have certain similarities and differences in their approach to personal transformation and growth.

Origin and Background

  • Interior Castles: St. Teresa of Avila, a 16th-century Spanish mystic and Carmelite nun, wrote “Interior Castles” as a guide for spiritual growth and contemplative prayer. The book is divided into seven “mansions” or levels, representing stages of spiritual development.

  • Dark Night of the Soul: This concept was introduced by St. John of the Cross, a Spanish mystic, poet, and Carmelite friar from the 16th century. The “Dark Night” is a metaphor for a period of spiritual crisis and purification that precedes union with the Divine.

  • The Shadow: The concept of the “Shadow” was developed by Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Carl Jung in the early 20th century. The Shadow represents the unconscious aspects of our personality that we are unaware of or choose to ignore, containing both negative and positive traits.
  • Similarities
  • All three concepts focus on the importance of self-examination and introspection for personal growth and spiritual development.
  • Each concept acknowledges the presence of darkness, struggle, or unknown elements in the process of growth, emphasizing that these aspects must be confronted and integrated to achieve wholeness.

  • All three teachings encourage the individual to persevere through challenging experiences and use them as opportunities for growth and self-discovery.
  • Differences
  • While both Interior Castles and Dark Night of the Soul are rooted in Christian mysticism, the Shadow is a psychological concept grounded in Jungian analytical psychology.

  • The Interior Castles outline a clear, structured path towards spiritual growth, whereas the Dark Night of the Soul and the Shadow focus more on the individual’s inner struggles and the process of integrating those experiences.

  • The Dark Night of the Soul specifically addresses the spiritual crisis and the feelings of abandonment, while the Shadow focuses on the unconscious aspects of the personality that can be both positive and negative.

Practical Applications

  • Interior Castles provides a roadmap for spiritual growth through contemplative prayer, meditation, and cultivating virtues.
  • The Dark Night of the Soul serves as a reminder that spiritual crises can be necessary for growth and that we should persevere in our faith during difficult times.

  • The concept of the Shadow can be applied to personal development through self-examination, self-awareness, and the integration of unconscious aspects of our personality, leading to a more balanced and authentic self.


The concepts of Interior Castles, Dark Night of the Soul, and the Shadow, though originating from different traditions, all offer valuable insights into the process of personal and spiritual growth. By understanding and applying these teachings, individuals can navigate the challenges of the spiritual journey and move towards greater self-awareness, wholeness, and connection with the Divine.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap